Page Not Found - DVDfever.co.uk
DVDfever.co.uk

404: Page not found

It looks like nothing was found at this location. Maybe try a search or one of the links below?

Archives

Categories

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox

Join other followers:

WP Twitter Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com

Dan Owen reviews

The Lord Of The Rings:
The Return of the King

'This Christmas The Journey Ends'

Viewed at Odeon, Lincoln Wharf

Cover

And so the journey comes to an end.

After five years of production, and three blockbuster movies, Peter Jackson's acclaimed trilogy of J.R.R Tolkien's novels finally comes to a close. The Return Of The King, after a prologue explaining the downfall of Gollum, picks up exactly where The Two Towers climaxed. Frodo and Sam are being shepherded by the treacherous Gollum towards Mordor to destroy the One Ring, wizard Gandalph and the rest of the Fellowship prepare to meet the full-force of Sauron's armies at the human city of Minus Tirith, and Aragorn must accept his destiny as heir to the throne of Gondor...

Third acts are always difficult in screenplays, and even more so for trilogies. While Fellowship had the unenviable task of explaining Tolkien's complicated Middle Earth, it was by far the most accessible movie due to its linear plot. The Two Towers successfully added complication and additional characters, but despite its fabulous finale at Helm's Deep, it was occasionally quite maudlin. The Return Of The King has to pull together all the plot-threads and weave them into a cohesive and entertaining last chapter. Unlike other movie franchises, the prospects of a sequel to the events of the movie are zero. The success of Jackson's trilogy rests quite heavily on Return Of The King - and what a burden that must be.

Of course, J.R.R Tolkien's books are the inspiration and guidelines for Jackson's movies - so Tolkien himself has to share some of any blame. But thankfully the successful literary trilogy has been perfectly realized on celluloid. Jackson has altered the ending quite drastically - making it far less apocryphal than Tolkien's, while the Two Towers sequence involving Shelob the giant spider has been mixed into the events of the final film instead. But these changes, and others, do not detract from an expertly handled piece of filmmaking.



Again, the cast provide audiences with truly memorably characters - now a solid part of movie legend. Unfortunately, some of the characters remain little more than background amusement (Legolas and Gimli, yet again), but others really do grow into something more substantial (Merry and Pippin's adventures in battle, and Sam's heroism, primarily). Liv Tyler's Arwen continues to be forced into a rather limp romance with Aragorn (a subplot shoved into the trilogy by Jackson for feminine audience appeal), and other potentially fascinating characters spend much of the movie with little to do. Miranda Otto's Éowyn is such a neglected character, who as compensation has a heroic sequence with the Nazgul-riding Witchking that goes some way to appeasement, but highlights how more interesting she could have been with a more immersive back-story.

WETA's special-effects continue to be a source of much admiration. They really do have a realism and vitality to them that other effects studios somehow haven't managed to capture with the same level of success. From CGI landscapes, rampaging beasts, giant trolls, swooping Nazguls, and the remarkably realistic Gollum, the studio has become the zenith for digital integration. Rarely does a visual effect detract from the story, or needlessly appear, with only a few shots badly composited and distracting to audiences. For the most part the sheer scale and breath-taking panorama's are beguiling and enchanting to behold.

Likewise, Howard Shore's score is magnificent and must now rank amongst one of the most beautifully composed music scores ever created for cinema - a truly wonderful collection of emotive and enthralling melodies. Elsewhere the technical brilliance of the production design, costumes and make-up are without doubt. The Return Of The King effectively provides audiences with everything that made the previous two movies so fantastic - good acting, an involving plot, stunning effects, rousing music, and brilliant design.



But there are problems, undoubtedly. While the film's pacing is exceptional (it feels like the shortest film, while actually being the longest!) the finale does drag on for too long - with the credits taking an eternity to materialize. Purists may also bemoan the movie's happier ending, at odds with the downbeat and more sobering novel. Also, while the battle at Minus Tirith is a technical marvel, it somehow lacks the atmosphere of the Helm's Deep siege from The Two Towers. It was also quite frustrating that Christopher Lee's Saruman doesn't even feature in the movie - which robs the trilogy of a satisfying conclusion for his character (who was practically the lead villain in the previous films!) Of course, the inevitable DVD extended edition should remedy some of these complaints...

On balance, The Return Of The King marks a grand end to what has been a remarkable filmmaking event of recent years. It's epic, visually stunning, character-driven and occasionally quite emotional. It will be very interesting to see how writer-director Peter Jackson's career progresses from here - will Rings hang around his neck like George Lucas' Star Wars? Or unlike Lucas, will Jackson break free of his phenomenon and create many more works of genius? Next up from the Kiwi director is a remake of King Kong - the film that inspired his filmmaking career. On a personal level, success with this Kong could be even more important than simply creating the greatest film trilogy ever made...


DIRECTION
SCREENPLAY
PERFORMANCES
SPECIAL FX
SOUND/MUSIC




OVERALL

And with hindsight (and with relation to each other) my scores for each film:

The Fellowship Of The Ring
The Two Towers
The Return Of The King


Trilogy Overall

Review copyright © Dan Owen, 2004.

E-mail Dan Owen

Read all three of Dan Owen's Lord of the Rings reviews:

[Up to the top of this page]

Page Not Found - DVDfever.co.uk

DVDfever.co.uk

404: Page not found

It looks like nothing was found at this location. Maybe try a search or one of the links below?

Archives

Categories

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox

Join other followers:

WP Twitter Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com