Dom Robinson reviews
- Cat.no: CDR 33020
- Running time: 91 minutes
- Year: 2002
- Pressing: 2003
- Region(s): 2, PAL
- Chapters: 22 plus extras
- Sound: Dolby Digital 5.1
- Languages: English, Hungarian, Russian
- Subtitles: 14 languages available
- Widescreen: 2.35:1 (Anamorphic Panavision)
- 16:9-Enhanced: Yes
- Macrovision: Yes
- Disc Format: DVD 9
- Price: £19.99
- Extras : Blossoms and Blood, Scopitones, Theatrical Trailers, Mattress Man Commercial,Deleted Scenes, Art
- Paul Thomas Anderson
(Boogie Nights, Cigarettes & Coffee, The Dirk Diggler Story, Hard Eight, Magnolia, Punch-Drunk Love, TV: Couch)
- Paul Thomas Anderson, Daniel Lupi and Joanne Sellar
- Paul Thomas Anderson
- Jon Brion
- Barry Egan: Adam Sandler
Lena Leonard: Emily Watson
Dean Trumbell: Philip Seymour Hoffman
Lance: Luis Guzman
Rico: Rico Bueno
Rhonda: Hazel Mailloux
Elizabeth: Mary Lenn Rajskub
In Punch-Drunk Love,Barry Egan is a single man who works in a warehouse which sells bizarrenovelty toys, he has seven sisters, who snipe at him and call him “Gay Boy”because he threw a hammer at a sliding door window when he was younger andone of his sisters, Elizabeth, is trying to set him up on a blind date, orrather arrangement at a dinner party.
He has an obsession with collecting airmail vouchers from copious amounts ofpurchased pudding and also an incredibly violent temper, stemming from abad experience with a phone-sex chatline which triggers him off and wheredoes the D&D Mattress Man company come in to all this?
To detail more than that would rob the film of its shock value at times.This is an engaging and unpredictable one, but at 83 minutes beforethe end credits roll it ends too quickly and too many elements are leftunresolved.
However, while you’re caught up in it, this might sound a cliche, but it doeshave funny and touching moments. To see Adam Sandler in a film like thisis a real find. Normally, he’s wasted in one flaccid so-called comedy afteranother which, sadly, he gets paid at least $20m apiece for, so he has noreason to stop making those for now since he won’t have made a bundle from amovie like this, but it would be nice to see him diversify because hecertainly can cut it here. Emily Watson keeps to her English accentand is simply gorgeous.
Visuals are employed with a fantastic 2.35:1 anamorphic widescreen canvas, onwhich to paint an early morning scene during which Barry comes to own astrange harmonium left at his place of work, and later the clean and coldemptiness of a supermarket.
There’s excellent use of cutting sound at key moments in the film, whichsurprise when delivered – so I won’t spoil these here – but which punctuatethe tension perfectly. Fast-percussion background music heightens the tensionof each required scene.
All the extras come on disc two, but aren’t as abundant as one would’ve thoughtfor requiring a second disc. Any film clips are non-anamorphic:
- Blossoms and Blood (12 mins):A montage of film clips, including some taken from different perspectives notseen in the main feature. Probably the closest thing to a music video, in away, but still something you’ll watch once only.
- Scopitones (4 mins): Brief music snippets of around 15-60 seconds each that don’t really work on theirown. Had they done so, the interesting way the video’s cut together would’vehad the desired effect.
- Trailers (7 mins): Three here. One standard one (2.20, anamorphic 2.35:1), one abstract onelabelled “Jeremy Blake’s Love” which more resembles the DVD main menus (1.23,non-anamorphic 2.35:1) and a shorter one, “Eat Tomorrow”, that highlightsthe romantic part of the plot (30 seconds, non-anamorphic 2.35:1).
- Mattress Man commercial (45 seconds): Philip Seymour Hoffman in a ‘commercial’ for his own company.
- Deleted Scenes (7 mins): Two here. The first, “The Sisters Call” (7:17), shows them doing just that, endlesslyand we also get an insight into Barry’s madness but it does go on too long.The second, “Are You From California?” (2:22), centres around the cashpointmachine, but I’ll say no more.
- Art (2½ mins): More of the main menu-style images set to an old tune (Anne Kerr – I’ve GoneNative Now), which just seems a bit pointless.
Overall, some rather disappointing extras that don’t make a whole lot of sense.The director can get away with such abstract behaviour in the film but itjust looks odd outside of that.
The main menus are nicely animated and scored, in keeping with the effects usedin the movie at times and there are subtitles in English, Arabic, Bulgarian,Croatian, Czech, Dutch, Greek, Hindi, Hungarian, Icelandic, Polish, Russian,Slovenian and Turkish. What a bizarre selection? Perhaps if they’d cut downon those and not had as many DD5.1 soundtracks, all the extras could’ve fiton disc one. The film has but 22 chapters to divide it.Strangely, subtitles for the extras are in English, Dutch, Italian and Spanish.Why use different ones for the extras alone that aren’t used for the movieitself?
Reviewer of movies, videogames and music since 1994. Aortic valve operation survivor from the same year. Running DVDfever.co.uk since 2000. Nobel Peace Prize winner 2021.